Hockey Trading Pins

We offer high-quality custom hockey pins at an affordable price. Our talented team of graphic designers have decades of experience crafting pins that are recognized throughout the hockey community. Let us create a memorable pin for your team’s next tournament or event that stands out from the crowd.

Why All-Star Trading Pins?


With a combined 60 years of experience making sports trading pins, we know how to get the job done. Put your trust in our talented team.


Higher quality makes your pins more sought after. We don't skimp when it comes to your pins. Only the best materials and expert craftsmanship.


We don't outsource your art to someone that doesn't understand hockey. Our designers US-based with extensive knowledge in hockey pins.


Not only are our pins priced competitively, but the quote you receive is what you pay. Free shipping to both the United States and Canada.

Hockey Pin Gallery

What's IncludeD
All these features and more are include free!

Our transparent pricing and unmatched customer service, make us the true All-Stars of the hockey trading pin industry. We offer impeccable designs, quality craftsmanship, and a level of transparency you won’t find anywhere else.

The design you receive from us is 100% custom. We don’t use stock templates or recycled artwork. Your team deserves a pin that is unique and we’ll help make that a reality.

Have a colorful logo? Not a problem. We offer up to 7 enamel colors in our standard pricing.

Our pins are made with at least a 1.5mm thickness. This provides a solid metal base that ensures your pin won’t crumble when handled. Other companies like to skimp here and use a thinner base. But we understand the added quality means a longer lasting product that can withstand drops and more.

Every pin we create over 1.5″ comes with dual clutches at no extra cost. This provides a security and stability when being worn. Our competitors will charge you extra for this.

All orders ship completely free to the United States & Canada (Canadian customers may need to pay Duty or Customs) using FedEx International Priority. Shipping typically takes 1-3 business days although there can be unforeseen delays.

Pin Add-Ons


Starting at $0.59 per pin.

Bobble Heads

Starting at $0.84 per pin.

Puzzle Pins

Varies by design & number of puzzle pieces.

See all pin Options

Starting at $0.10 per pin.


The most common questions about our hockey trading pins.

All our soft enamel hockey pins are comprised of a steel or iron base metal. They are then struck with a custom die based off the custom shape and design of your pin. These are then plated with nickel, brass, copper, or a custom paint color.

Pins are then hand-painted with colored enamel to fill in the recessed areas. The pin is finally polished to create a beautiful finish.

Custom hockey pins have a production cycle of around within 2-3 weeks following payment. Larger order quantities may add a couple days to the production cycle.

Before placing your order, we will give you an estimated ship date. We advise placing orders as early into the season as possible to avoid the rush and allow ample time for unforeseen shipping delays.

Our talented art department can work with just about anything you have. Whether that’s a logo from your team site or a scribble of an idea on a napkin.

For the best results, we ask that you be as descriptive as possible with what you would like. Providing artwork, links to social media, or any other pertinent information that gets our creative juices flowing.

There is an option on our quote form to include as much design notes as you’d like. And if you don’t like how it looks, we offer unlimited revisions.

Our trading pin prices are based on the size, quantity, and any additional features you have chosen. Please check out our pricing chart or fill out the quote form to get a more precise estimate.

We also understand that many hockey teams need to work within the confines of a budget. If you let us know what that is upfront, we can help design a pin that works for you.

Shipping is and always has been free. The quote you receive from us is for everything. As an Oregon based company, there is no sales tax.

Yes, we offer free shipping to our Canadian friends above the border. You would only be responsible for the duties imposed by the Canadian Government.

Please note that customs in Canada can be a bit slower to process packages. We recommend giving yourselves a few extra days cushion when placing an order.

For a single tournament, we recommend between 30-50 pins per team member. This allows for ample trading and to save a few as keepsakes. If your team plays in multiple tournaments a year, we recommend 100 per player. The higher quantity will also help drop the cost per pin by a significant amount.

We have been lucky to make custom hockey pins for teams and organizations of all levels. Below are a few:
  • Mite
  • Squirt
  • PeeWee
  • Bantam
  • Midget Minor
  • Junior
  • AAU
  • Tournoi Pee Wee Quebec
  • USA Hockey
  • High School
  • College and University
  • Minor League
  • ….and many more