The Leader in Sports Trading Pins

We combine high-quality materials and a proven manufacturing process with our world-class design team to create the best sports trading pins on the market. Our friendly, knowledgeable staff is ready to walk you through the process of creating a memorable keepsake. And we’ll do it all at an affordable price.

How This Works

Step 1 - Request a Quote

Take a minute to fill out our handy quote form. It includes how many pins you need, the size, which optional add-ons you want, and your design. Be sure to include as much detail in the notes as possible so our design team can get it just right.

1-3 Days

Step 2 - Pin Design & Options

Next the design team will step in and put together a digital proof that shows you what your trading pin will look like. Our art department is entirely based in the United States. We don't outsource your artwork. Your digital proof will also include a quote that includes everything.

Step 3 - Finalize Your Order

With a digital proof and quote in hand, you can either sign off on it or request changes. Remember that we will make unlimited revisions to your design. Our goal is to make the trading pin you have envisioned. After signing off, you can pay online and have the order sent to production.

10 Minutes
2-3 Weeks

Step 4 - Production

Here is where we turn your vision into reality. Using high-quality materials and a trusted manufacturing process, we'll build your custom trading pin from scratch. And of course, they'll be covered under our 100% satisfaction guarantee.

Step 5 - Shipping

Lastly, your pins will ship using a major carrier (UPS, FedEx, DHL) and be at your door within a few days. All our pins ship free in the United States. You're now ready to show-off, trade, and enjoy your trading pins.

2-3 Days

Why All-Star Trading Pins?


Over 60 years of combined experience making trading pins. Our helpful team is based in the United States.


We use the highest quality materials & hand paint each pin. Pins 1.5" or larger include 2 clutches.


Our US-based art department is filled with talented graphic designers who have experience designing pins.


Find a better deal elsewhere? We will try to match it. Our prices includes everything from design to shipping.

What's IncludeD
We include all of the following features for free!

Unlike the competition, we aim to be transparent with our pricing. That’s why the quote you receive is what you pay. There are no hidden fees, taxes, or shipping costs.

Our design team will create a completely custom design for you. No templates here, your pin will be unique and includes unlimited revisions.

Included in your pin order is up to 7 enamel colors. Our quality paint produces a stunning final result that makes your team logo pop.

Our custom pins use a minimum of 1.5mm thick (as opposed to 1.2mm for many competitors) metal. This provides a strong base and proper textures that make every detail stand out.

Dual clutches are included for free on any pin that is 1.5″ or larger. This provides more stability when in use and avoids spinning.

Shipping is always free when you order from us. We’ll provide tracking information as soon as your pins ship from our factory.

Types of Pins

Soft Enamel Pins

The most popular type of trading pin.

Offset Printed Pins

Excellent when you have gradients or complex graphics.

Browse by Sport or Event

What our Customers Think

Thanks again for the great work, customer service, and excellent communication.

I will definitely be recommending your company to anyone…


Shemek Pawlik

Got them today! I am thoroughly impressed with the communication, speed of service/delivery, and quality of your products/company.

I will definitely order again!


Leanna Victoria